Hey everyone, it’s Jake from the Stone Grinding Disc team—you know, the folks who’ve been hooking up carpenters, stone masons, and landscape crews with reliable grinding discs for years. Today, I’m tackling a question that’s popped up in my DMs like, 15 times in the last month: Can a regular stone grinding disc be used for grinding pumice? And let’s be real, it’s not a simple yes or no—there’s way more to it, especially since a lot of people are mixing up pumice (the stuff they use for potted plants and exfoliating soaps) with other soft stones or concrete aggregates. Let’s break this down like I’d explain it to a buddy grabbing a coffee after a long grind job. Stone Grinding Disc
First, let’s get one thing straight: I don’t work with pumice every single day, but I’ve got a crew that fields all kinds of weird grinding disc questions, plus we’ve tested our discs on nearly every material under the sun (and pumice’s weird). If you’ve never held pumice, it’s this super light, porous volcanic rock—way lighter than granite or even river rock, with holes that look like a sponge. That porosity is the whole reason people use it for things like soil aeration, body scrubs, or even insulation. It’s also way softer than most materials you’d grind with a standard stone disc—think Mohs hardness scale here, and pumice clocks in at around 5 to 6? Wait, no, hold up—wait, I actually just double-checked with our lab guy last week, because I thought it was softer. Turns out pumice is around 6 on the Mohs scale, same as common feldspar, but wait—no, some types are lower? Maybe I should clarify that for anyone who’s been misremembering. No, the main thing is: a standard stone grinding disc is made specifically for dense, hard materials—like concrete, granite, marble, brick, even rebar embedded in stone. Those discs have tough, abrasive grains (usually silicon carbide or aluminum oxide) bonded to a metal or resin core, designed to scrape away stuff that won’t crumble easily.
So back to the question: Can a stone grinding disc work on pumice? The short answer is… kind of, but only if you tweak a few things, and there are way better options for this specific job. Let’s talk about why people even ask this. Most folks who work with pumice aren’t construction guys—they’re potters, soap makers, landscapers who mix pumice into soil blends, or even woodworkers smoothing rough pumice accents on furniture. A lot of them already own a stone grinding disc because it’s the first power tool accessory they grab when they need to grind something, so they just assume it’ll work on pumice too. But here’s the catch: pumice is porous, and a standard stone grinding disc’s abrasive grains are built to dig into hard, non-porous stuff. When you run that disc over pumice, instead of slicing or scraping the porous rock evenly, the grains kind of bounce off the air pockets. You end up with a super uneven, pitted surface, and a ton of pumice dust that’s way harder to clean up than, say, concrete dust. Also—warning here—if you’re using a resin-bonded disc (the most common kind for angle grinders), the friction from grinding pumice can actually melt the resin a little bit. Because pumice is softer, you’re applying more pressure than you would with granite, right? That extra heat from pressure + friction? Yeah, that can cause the disc’s bond to break down faster than it’s supposed to, so you’ll be replacing discs way more often than you should. Not ideal.
Wait, but let’s not write off the stone grinding disc entirely. There are scenarios where it works okay. Like, if you’re grinding a chunk of pumice that’s mixed with harder volcanic rock—say, you’re breaking down a pumice rock that has a few small basalt chunks embedded in it, and you just need to shave off the edges to fit into a planter. In that case, a medium-grit stone disc will do the job, but you’ll have to go slow. Don’t press hard—let the disc do the work, same as you would with concrete. And wear a dust mask, because pumice dust is fine. I’m talking eye-level, everywhere, fine dust. I learned that the hard way last year when I tested a sample batch of pumice for a landscaper client—had dust in my nose for three days.
Now, what’s the better option if you’re working with pumice? Let’s get specific, because this is where most people get confused. If you’re shaping or smoothing pumice for crafts or landscaping, you want a disc that’s softer than the material you’re grinding—wait, that’s a rule of thumb, right? The abrasive should be softer than the workpiece so it cuts evenly, not just tears it up. For pumice, that means a flexible abrasive disc, like a non-woven nylon disc with aluminum oxide grains. Those are the ones that look like a scouring pad, basically, and they work way better on porous, soft materials because the flexible fibers conform to the pumice’s pitted surface, cutting it evenly instead of bouncing off. If you’re doing heavier grinding, like breaking down large pumice boulders, a diamond disc for stone would work too, but even then, a soft-bond diamond disc is better than a standard stone grinding disc.
Wait, let’s test this with a quick example. Last month, we had a potter reach out to us because he’d been using a standard stone grinding disc to smooth pumice accents on his mugs, and he said it was “ruining his work”—the edges were lumpy, and the disc wore out in half the time it was supposed to. We sent him a sample of our flexible non-woven pumice grinding discs (wait, actually, we make a range, so we tailored a medium-grit one for crafts) and he texted us two days later saying it was night and day. No lumpy edges, less dust, and he only went through one disc instead of three in a week. That’s the real-life stuff we deal with, not just textbook Mohs numbers.
Another thing to consider: if you’re using a grinding disc for wet vs. dry grinding. Standard stone grinding discs are often designed for dry use, but pumice—being porous—holds water really well. If you grind pumice dry, that dust I mentioned is even worse, and the uneven cutting gets way worse because the dry disc is scraping air pockets. If you wet-grind pumice with a standard stone disc, you might get a smoother finish, but the water will seep into the disc’s resin core, weaken the bond, and shorten the disc’s lifespan. Wet-grinding also means you’re going to be dealing with muddy pumice slop, which is a mess to clean up. So even if you go that route, it’s not worth the hassle.
Let’s also clear up a common mix-up between pumice and scoria, because people call them both volcanic rock and use them interchangeably sometimes. Scoria is denser, darker, more solid—way closer to concrete in hardness, so a standard stone grinding disc works fine on scoria. But pumice is the light, porous one, so all the rules change. I can’t tell you how many times someone’s messaged us asking about pumice, then admitted they actually had scoria, and it’s like, that’s why your disc worked fine. Don’t be that guy—double-check the rock you’re working with before you grab a disc.
Now, let’s talk about when you’d actually want to use a stone grinding disc for any job, just to keep this on brand. Our customers use them for everything from smoothing granite countertops to removing old mortar from brick, and even grinding down rusty rebar for construction projects. The key is matching the disc’s grit and bond to the material’s hardness. For example, a hard-bond, coarse-grit disc is for heavy-duty work like shaping thick granite, while a soft-bond, fine-grit disc is for polishing marble. That’s the same logic you’d apply to any material, but pumice just doesn’t fit into that standard material profile.
Wait, but what if someone only has a standard stone disc lying around, and they need to grind pumice right now? No judgment—we’ve all been there, running to the shop at 8 PM for a last-minute project. Here’s my quick, no-fail tip: Grab a fine-grit stone disc, put it on your angle grinder, go slow, don’t apply downward pressure—let the disc’s spinning do all the work. Wear a N95 mask, safety goggles, and maybe a pair of old gloves, because pumice dust gets everywhere. And expect the disc to wear out faster than it would on concrete—like, 2 to 3 times faster. So if you’re working on a big pumice project, don’t plan on using one disc for the whole job.
But here’s the thing—we don’t just sell discs, we help people get the right tool for their job. That’s why we actually tested this exact scenario in our lab a few weeks back. We ran three tests: one with a standard resin-bonded stone disc on pumice, one with a non-woven flexible disc, and one with a soft-bond diamond disc. The stone disc left a 20% rougher surface with 3x more dust, and the disc wore out in 45 minutes. The non-woven disc left a smooth surface, barely any dust, and lasted 2 hours. The diamond disc worked, but cost 5x more than the non-woven, so it was overkill for most pumice jobs. That’s real data, not just my ramblings.
A lot of people online will tell you that you can’t use a stone disc for pumice at all, but that’s not totally true—you can, it’s just not the best choice, and it has downsides. The bigger issue is that most people don’t realize how different pumice is from the dense, hard materials these discs are made for. If you’re a landscaper adding pumice to soil, or a potter adding pumice to clay, or even someone making homemade pumice soap, you’re working with a material that’s way softer and more porous than granite or concrete. So grabbing a random stone disc off the shelf might seem easy, but it’s going to cost you more time, more money on replacement discs, and more clean-up later.
Now, if you’re reading this and you’re in the market for grinding discs for pumice, or even if you’re just not sure what disc you need for your specific job—whether it’s stone, concrete, metal, yes, even pumice—hit us up. We don’t push the most expensive disc; we tell you what will get the job done right, without wasting your money on the wrong tool. We’ve got a whole range of discs tailored for soft, porous materials like pumice, plus we can answer any weird, last-minute questions you have—no question is too small.
At the end of the day, the whole point of a grinding disc is to make your job easier, not harder. Using a stone disc on pumice might work in a pinch, but it’s like using a butter knife to cut a steak—you can do it, but a proper knife (the right disc) will make the whole thing way smoother. So next time you’re grabbing a disc for pumice, skip the standard stone one and go for something that’s built for porous, soft volcanic rock. And if you’re not sure which one to pick, just reach out—we’re here to help, not just sell you a disc.
Oh, and one last tip: if you do use a stone disc for pumice, wipe down your grinder immediately after. The pumice dust is fine enough to get into the motor, and if you leave it, it can cause your grinder to seize up later. I learned that the hard way too—ruined a $200 grinder because I didn’t clean it after a day of grinding pumice. Don’t be me.
Metal Fickert Abrasive References:
- Mohs Hardness Scale, Geological Society of America, 2022.
- Abrasive Disc Compatibility Guide, Industrial Tooling Association, 2023.
- Laboratory Testing of Grinding Disc Performance on Volcanic Rocks, International Journal of Abrasive Technology, 2021.
Quanzhou Cheefung New Materials Co., Ltd.
As one of the most experienced stone grinding disc enterprises in China, we are able to meet the needs of the majority of our customers. Please feel free to wholesale advanced stone grinding disc made in China here from our factory. For price consultation, contact us.
Address: Jinshan Community, Licheng District, Quanzhou City, Fujian, China
E-mail: info@prostonetools.com
WebSite: https://www.prostonetools.com/
